Up tornado alley

The first time I heard a tornado siren was during the first summer I spent in Indiana. Sitting alone in a computer room at first I ignored the wail in the background. Then a janitor came in and informed me the sound I was hearing was a tornado siren and I needed to get out of the building. Leaving the building didn’t sound like anything I really wanted to do (and in hindsight I think I misinterpreted–probably the janitor meant I should go to the tornado shelter, which was accessed by leaving the building) so I asked the first group of people I came across–a group of meteorology grad students–what I should do.

Instead of directing me to the safety of the basement or the tornado shelter, they took me to the roof observatory, where we watched the storm rage around us, hoping to glimpse a tornado but never spotting one.

I tell this story to make a couple of points: one, there are people who are crazy enough to actually want to see a tornado, and two, weather is a big deal in the midwest.

Most of my husband’s family lives in the midwest or the south. Over the last year my husband and I have gone from being related to nobody directly impacted by a tornado to being related to three families who’ve suffered significant property damage from tornadoes, two of them in the last week. Fortunately, nobody we know was hurt–only homes and businesses were damaged–but the same can not be said for at least 200 people across the southeast and midwest.

Being an Earth scientist watching natural disasters unfold is always a little strange. While the magnitude of human suffering is always heart-wrenching, the magnitude of the geologic event is almost never truly surprising, nor is the damage the Earth is capable of visiting on us. We live on an active planet–a good thing, since life would be less probable in the absence of plate tectonics and impossible without a hydrologic cycle. But while that activity sustains the biosphere, it causes the periodic cataclysms we find so distressing. The vigor of the rock cycle returns carbon dioxide to the atmosphere that would otherwise languish in solid form, but it also brings us earthquakes capable of leveling cities and spawning tsunamis that scour the land and intensify the damage from the shaking, as we saw both in Sumatra and more recently in Japan. The hydrologic cycle moves water from the salty oceans onto land, where it nourishes the ecosystems in which we live, but it does so in a very uneven fashion, producing everything from intense droughts to intense hurricanes, from gentle mists to thunderstorms and tornadoes.

We are familiar with the current patterns of weather and climate, with current patterns of tectonic activity. Having grown up in Utah I know snow falls in the winter and is mostly melted by the end of May, which means reservoirs are required to have water available through the rest of the year. I know Indiana is wet all year long, allowing even me with my brown thumb amazing (to me) success in the garden. Being a geologist, working on paleoclimate, I am also aware those basic weather patterns–dryness in the west and wetness in the east–have persisted through the last few thousand years.

Some aspects of the climate system don’t leave behind a good record geologists can use to reconstruct things like frequency or intensity. Tornadoes, for example, don’t leave a tangible, unambiguous signal in any geologic archive. Hurricanes can leave some signal of their passage, but the signal is far from unambiguous and probably misses smaller events. Lacking an archive to examine, Earth scientists turn to climate models to estimate changes in the behavior of the weather–changes in frequency or intensity of storms and droughts.

The results so far suggest we’re in for more severe weather and more intense hurricanes, though possibly fewer of them.

Attribution of extreme weather to climate change is difficult, though some attempts have been made. The problem is, there’s a lot of natural variability in the weather, so it’s nearly impossible to pin any given storm or drought, or weather event at all on climate change. Probably we’ll go years before there’s another storm of this magnitude, before there’s another Katrina. But those storms will come, and, instead of being once in a century storms, they’ll become two or three in a century, or once in a decade.

It’s a future that will probably only make my tornado-crazy friends happy.


8 responses to “Up tornado alley

  1. Tatiana April 29, 2011 at 6:48 pm

    I’m always thinking people who like to watch storms are like my friends at Balliol College in Oxford, UK who decided to put a bullet in the fire to see what happened. Brilliant, all of them, and so incredibly stupid as well. Perhaps it’s better to get some idea of guns (or of storms) and the damage they can cause before one goes gallivanting into the line of fire.

    I grew up with them, and with a mother who was terrified of them and tried hard not to pass her terror to us. It makes a lot of sense to me to go to shelter when there’s a tornado seen on radar heading my way. Sure, 99 will pass me by untouched, but that hundredth one is a doozy. So many people on the news just now attest how their safe place still stood and gave them shelter when the rest of their houses blew away. Sadly, so many who didn’t have or go to a safe place are now gone.

    Climate change or no, tornadoes are hazards that are best minimized by taking shelter, not driving, or strolling outside when they’re approaching. A few close calls will surely teach us that.

  2. Mark Brown April 29, 2011 at 8:25 pm

    Thanks Kristine. These are some wise thoughts.

    Your post reminded me of the article from Slate.


  3. Kristine N April 30, 2011 at 8:59 am

    Mark, in what way?

  4. Mark Brown April 30, 2011 at 2:10 pm

    Kristine, this part:

    “And just as important, we’ll make better policy if we admit we don’t know and can’t control everything while continuing to stand by the things we do know. To admit uncertainty isn’t to undermine science — rather, it’s essential for making policy that’s science-based. It will help us better assess what we can feasibly do and prepare for the things we can’t.”

  5. Brad April 30, 2011 at 2:11 pm

    This is awesome, Kristine. I co-taught a course called Biology, Society, and Culture, and we did an entire unit on the relationship between shifting climate patterns and human activity (both recent anthropogenic trends as well as the likely impact of shifting patterns on our early evolution and adaptive plasticity as a species).

  6. Leisa Bagnato May 24, 2011 at 11:30 pm

    It is such a travesty with these recent catastrophes that have been whirling around our nation. I pray to God to provide solace to all the victims and help them by means of this dark time.

  7. Mike H. May 26, 2011 at 2:54 am

    This has become a staggering Tornado season in the US.

  8. Kristine N May 26, 2011 at 10:54 pm

    Indeed, it has been a staggering tornado season. I really hope things calm down soon.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: